FREE TRAINING /

Defining and Creating an Effective Severity Scale – EN ISO 14971:2019+A11:2021

Richard Tully
6 minutes 9 seconds

Lesson Overview

This video, presented by Richard Tully (Director of Compliant Medical Devices), explores a procedural approach to defining a severity scale for risk management, ensuring compliance with EN ISO 14971.

  • A well-defined severity scale ensures clarity and consistency in risk assessment.
  • The scale must be appropriate to the device and understood by the entire risk team.
  • Risk teams are multidisciplinary, typically including members from design, production, quality, regulatory, and clinical teams. Additional roles, such as installation, servicing, and post-market surveillance, may also be involved.
  • A common risk language helps prevent misunderstandings during risk analysis.

Importance of Defining Severity in Risk Management

  • ISO 14971 is the harmonised risk management standard for medical devices.
  • Technical Report (TR) 24971 supplements ISO 14971, providing implementation guidance.
  • Each medical device requires a risk management plan, which includes severity planning.

Regulatory Background

  • Severity of harm is typically visualised as a sliding scale from negligible harm to death.
  • Zero harm is not a valid descriptor—if something is classified as a hazard, it must have the potential to cause harm.
  • Large manufacturers often use scales with up to 10 levels, attempting to cover all possible harm gradations.
  • The problem?
    • Ambiguity in defining intermediate levels leads to debates and inconsistencies.
    • Differences between severity levels are subjective and open to interpretation.
    • The only measurable anchors are death (most severe) and negligible harm (least severe).

Understanding Severity Scales

  • Instead of using a generic severity scale, the video suggests defining device-specific severity levels.
  • Example: Syringe Severity Scale
    • Negligible Harm: A cracked syringe causes a delay in treatment, but the healthcare professional simply uses another syringe.
    • Minor Harm: A syringe seal failure leads to an underdose and a mess to clean up, requiring the healthcare professional to estimate the remaining dose.
    • Serious Harm: A discarded syringe could cause a cut or a fall.
    • These three levels are clear and directly tied to the device’s risks, reducing ambiguity.
  • Example: Syringe Pump Severity Scale
    • Negligible Harm: A delay while the healthcare professional programs the device.
    • Serious Harm:
      • Using a syringe of the wrong diameter with a critical drug could have severe consequences.
      • Missed key presses could result in an underdose, leading to ineffective treatment.
      • Bruising from a misplaced needle or power cables obstructing the patient area.
    • The complexity of the syringe pump necessitates more severity levels than a simple syringe.

Benefits of a Device-Specific Severity Scale

  • Ensures clarity: The whole risk team understands the scale because it is based on real-world device examples.
  • Minimises debates and inconsistencies:
    • Instead of arbitrary definitions, severity levels are directly linked to the device’s risks.